How do I write a good peer review?

Let’s learn how do I write a good peer review. The most accurate or helpful solution is served by Quora.

There are ten answers to this question.

Best solution

Answer:

Focus on the behaviours and not the person's characteristics. Give examples so that the peer can see...

Read more

Wendy Pat Fong at Quora Mark as irrelevant Undo

Other solutions

Literature Review help?

I have an assignment to write a Literature Review using 7 scholarly sources (peer-reviewed journals and/or academic books) It also says to "provide a 750-1000 word overview of ...show more

Answer:

No, you probably don't want to just list and summarize each source sequentially like that. You're supposed...

Read more

KGD2H6SI6LDAGU5ITXV3EA3KMY at Yahoo! Answers Mark as irrelevant Undo

Help me write my MA thesis...PLEASE?

Okay, this is a long-shot, I know, but I need help finding information about someone referenced in a random Ph.D thesis I came across on teh intarwebs. His ideas are about the use of patterning in High School English education, and I'd like to acknowledge...

Answer:

Possibly?

Read more

guster4lovers at Ask.Metafilter.Com Mark as irrelevant Undo

Would you write a negative review?

I hired an electrician company to change my electric baseboard heater. I needed the one done in a few days. They charge $40 to come out and look. If you hire them they will put that money to the total bill. Well, being at my home now, I told him that...

Answer:

I'm sorry but you should have called around first before having the first company even attempt to do...

Read more

The Correct Answer is at Yahoo! Answers Mark as irrelevant Undo

Has anyone had to deal with a peer review board at the company. like a grievance group of managers and hourly.

filed a challenge on a write up i received, spoke to one of the panel members about my situation because he works in my department. day before review he disqualifies himself because i spoke with him. the morning of the review, hr went looking for replacement...

Answer:

Its not discrimination. Just an oversite on their part. Don't go talking to anyone else about this until...

Read more

lovedoc_... at Yahoo! Answers Mark as irrelevant Undo

What does the "peer review ring" incident at SAGE journals say about the peer-review process in general?

Scholarly journal retracts 60 articles, smashes ‘peer review ring’ Nayfeh is an eminent scholar in the field of nonlinear vibration theory, and apparently he resigned in either shame or disgust from his editorial position. I almost...

Answer:

It says first and most obviously that crooks and criminals often get away with their misconduct, especially...

Read more

Richard Weinberg at Quora Mark as irrelevant Undo

How do you write a quality book review?

Let's say I finished reading a novel. Let's say I want to write a review of said novel. What would I need to include in a review? What should I avoid? What gives a book review weight, and distinguishes it from an 'I Liked The Book Because It Was Good...

Answer:

A question with no simple answer. Is a book review the same as a critique? ~ Could be. The two terms...

Read more

emilia at Yahoo! Answers Mark as irrelevant Undo

How often do researchers from peer-review journals let others see their original data sets?

I'm curious because I want to play around with data sets for fun on some statistics software I'm teaching myself, plus I want to create equations to describe/predict things I find interesting in peer-review journals. I've been looking at peer-review...

Answer:

Very often. Most journals and even funding agencies require that all published data should be made available...

Read more

10 Thousand at Yahoo! Answers Mark as irrelevant Undo

How often do researchers from peer-review journals let others see their original data sets?

I'm curious because I want to play around with data sets for fun on some statistics software I'm teaching myself, plus I want to create equations to describe/predict things I find interesting in peer-review journals. I've been looking at peer-review...

Answer:

If you could contact the author I'm sure you might be able to arrange something. Depends on the person...

Read more

10 Thousand at Yahoo! Answers Mark as irrelevant Undo

Could open peer review replace single-blind as the dominant form of peer-review for academic articles? What are the obstacles?

Here open peer review means that either the reviewers comments, or identity, or both are available for anyone to see.

Answer:

I did participate in open peer review during my postdoc, both as a ...

Read more

Alan J. Salmoni at Quora Mark as irrelevant Undo

Related Q & A:

Just Added Q & A:

Find solution

For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.

  • Got an issue and looking for advice?

  • Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.

  • Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.

Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.